(Originally posted elsewhere; cross-posted in case of deletion.)
Since it is impossible under the circumstances to state my objections to antisemitism on philosophic grounds—for it is a wide topic, as diverse in its ramifications as the crimes and abuses with which the Jews have been charged—I shall content myself with a brief description of its political consequences:
* It is divisive - witness the present discussion!
* It turns people away. People otherwise receptive to nationalism and race realism are repelled by its association with antisemitism;
* It makes coalition-building extremely difficult, if not impossible. If we ever reverse the tide of Third World immigration, it will be for a great plurality of reasons, not strictly racial. Nationalists will have to make their voices heard amongst the clamor of other interest groups, and align themselves, as much as possible without sacrificing their core principles, with mainstream forces whose interests overlap with their own.
* It diverts our attention from activities, more fruitful in their issue, with which the public are broadly sympathic. Examples include immigration restriction, opposition to affirmative action policies, and the promotion of white culture. It tarnishes those same activities by way of association.
Even if we grant the Jewish Question as it is here treated a certain academic interest, yet as an article of faith to be signed, as a doctrine to be professed, its consquences have been utterly disastrous for the pro-white movement.
25 October, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
[b]"* It is divisive - witness the present discourse!"[/b]
I agree; bringing up the Jewish Question, and spending more time attacking the Jews, than trying to alert Whites (as David Duke is doing) is very dangerous, and could more than compensate for the good we get done by talking about matters which are not anti-Semitic.
[b]"* It turns people away. People otherwise receptive to nationalism and race realism are repelled by its association with antisemitism;"[/b]
It does turn people away. It has even almost officially turned me away (although I would still be opposed to our extinction) from the official movement (very recently,nonetheless) . I think we should avoid the Jewish Question, completely, if not at least from a genetic basis.
[b]"* It makes coalition-building extremely difficult, if not impossible. If we ever reverse the tide of Third World immigration, it will be for a great plurality of reasons, not strictly racial. Nationalists will have to make their voices heard amongst the clamor of other interest groups, and align themselves, as much as possible without sacrificing their core principles, with mainstream forces whose interests overlap with their own."[/b]
I think the Jews are racially White, but that is beside the point. I do agree, we should support immigration restrictions, while still officially transcending race. We should also support White civil rights out of principle, especially with the current PC climate.
[b]"* It diverts our attention from activities, more fruitful in their issue, with which the public are broadly sympathic. Examples include immigration restriction, opposition to affirmative action policies, and the promotion of white culture. It tarnishes those same activities by way of association."[/b]
I agree; it defeats the purpose.
[b]"Even if we grant the Jewish Question as it is here treated a certain academic interest, yet as an article of faith to be signed, as a doctrine to be professed, its consquences have been utterly disastrous for the pro-white movement."[/b]
Pure "academic" anti-Semitism (a form of ethnic conflict, when from other Whites; and a form of racial conflict, when from non-whites) would divert attention and emotion from where it should be. It should be about self-preservation. I don't advocate secession and/or armed rebellion; but White Nationalists will only pay 'lip service' during a likely 2nd American Civil War. Most White Nationalist militias and the future official White American ethnic army will be too focused on the Federal Government, Blacks, Brown Hispanics, and other non-Whites, to destroy the Jewish people.
Post a Comment